Skip to content

Keynote

Can a personal guarantee be challenged?

17 Nov 2026

•

3 min read

Share

The cases going through the courts reflect the economic environment where personal guarantees (PGs) and indemnities are regularly demanded by creditors, especially from directors of companies. They are then enforced against those directors upon the company’s default, by bankruptcy proceedings as a quick and effective recovery method.

Enforcement of a PG usually takes the initial form of service of a statutory demand because it regularly prompts a positive response. The courts will enforce a PG if it is properly drafted and constructed. However, the court will also entertain an application to set aside a statutory demand (and stop the bankruptcy procedure) if:

  • there is a substantial and genuine ground of dispute of the PG debt (the insolvency court not being the appropriate venue for a dispute), or
  • the debtor has a cross-claim against the creditor, or
  • the debtor has a set-off against the creditor, or
  • the creditor has other security (such as a charging order).

In this Keynote, Restructuring & Insolvency Consultant Solicitor Tony Sampson outlines the defences available to defeat liability under a PG.

Personal guarantee defences

  1. The construction of the PG. Is the PG actually enforceable in law? Does it have certainty? Does it have the necessary contractual elements? More obviously, is it dated, is it signed, and does it have the correct parties? All these points can be easily checked.
  2. Misrepresentation. Has there been any misrepresentation by the creditor? Are there any untrue material statements made by the creditor which induced the borrower to enter into the PG? In one recent case, the creditor allegedly stated that the director who gave the PG would not lose his beneficial interest in his company; the PG was thwarted because of that misrepresentation. However, the courts maintain that there is a difference between actionable misrepresentations and mere informal assurances.
  3. Duress and undue influence. Was the PG signed under pressure and therefore avoidable? This is always difficult to prove if independent legal advice was sought and given or the PG debtor was legally represented. It is also notoriously difficult to prove if the PG debtor did not complain immediately. Undue influence will usually require some breach of a position of trust by the creditor.
  4. Has there been subsequent correspondence between the creditor and the debtor? Recent case law has indicated that PGs can be amended by subsequent correspondence and representations and still be enforceable (notwithstanding any shortcomings in the original PG).
  5. An unusual defence but one which is used in extreme circumstances. Would it be successful? The defamation would have to be substantiated and show that the defamatory statement caused or was likely to cause serious harm to the PG debtors’ reputation and quantifiable losses.

What about if the loan (and associated PG) is sold by the creditor to a debt purchaser? Recent case law indicates that this is acceptable and a liability under the PG remains.

Even more intriguing is that it seems from case law that a judgment obtained by the creditor in respect of a PG will not be overturned, notwithstanding that a fraud had been committed by a third party unconnected with the litigation.

What about the Limitation Act and the time limits within which a creditor must bring a claim under a PG? Again, it was recently reaffirmed that under the Limitation Act, time begins not when the individual enters into the PG, but rather when the demand is made by the creditor. The relevant time is 6 years for a straightforward contract and 12 years for a deed. Is a claim under the PG time-barred and therefore unrecoverable?

So, in this time of economic uncertainty, where PGs are being demanded regularly and being enforced with equal regularity via statutory demands and bankruptcy, defences may be utilised to attack the bankruptcy process and the PG.

If you have questions or concerns about personal guarantees, please contact Tony Sampson.

For further information please contact:

Tony Sampson

Consultant Solicitor

020 3319 3700

tony.sampson@keystonelaw.co.uk

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. It should not be used as a substitute for legal advice relating to your particular circumstances. Please note that the law may have changed since the date of this article.

Share